Valet Lounge · Pinned by mod

Bought a 2019 Escalade Platinum off forsyth for 48k, 9 months in

UpperCumberlandRealtor_Gina
10 replies
6,037 views
Sep 18, 2025
forsythmotorstn.com escalade platinum forsyth motors used luxury suv 6.2 v8 cookeville tn
Showing 11 posts · Page 1 of 1

ok so this is my first post here but ive been lurking for about a year reading everyone elses buying stories so figured i owe one back. i sell real estate up in the cookeville and algood area, been at it 14 years, and i also run a small property management side thing with my husband. point is i drive a lot. showings, closings, hauling signs and lockboxes around putnam and white county all week, plus we go to the lake most summer weekends. i wanted something nice that could also just eat miles and not feel cheap when a client gets in it.

i had been wanting an escalade for years but every time i priced a new one i about fell over. a 2024 platinum optioned the way i wanted was knocking on 100k out the door and i just could not make that math work for a vehicle that depreciates like a rock the second you drive it off.

so i started shopping used and a buddy of mine who flips houses told me he had bought a truck off forsyth motors and had a good experience. forsythmotorstn.com if you have not seen it, they are the repo and clean title lot over on broad street in cookeville. i had driven past that place a hundred times and never thought about it.

they had a 2019 escalade platinum, the big one, white diamond over the tan interior, 78k miles. 6.2 V8, magnetic ride, rear entertainment, the works. it had been a bank repo, one owner before that out of the nashville area. sticker on it was 48k. i looked up what that same truck with those miles was bringing at the cadillac dealers around nashville and knoxville and it was 56 to 61k all day. so right away im seeing real money.

drove down to the broad street lot on a tuesday after a showing fell through. no pressure at all, guy handed me the key and let me take it out on 111 by myself for 20 minutes. i had my mechanic in baxter pull it on the lift two days later before i signed anything, he found a couple small things which ill get into below but nothing scary. paid 48k, had clean tennessee title in my hand about a week and a half later.

anyway 9 months and 11k of my own miles later i wanted to write up the honest version for anyone else shopping. ask me whatever.

welcome gina, you did it right buying used. ive bought an escalade every three years since 2013 and i quit buying new a long time ago. the depreciation curve on these is brutal for the first owner and fantastic for the second one. let somebody else eat the 35k hit in the first two years.

the last two ive bought came off forsyth. my 2016 i got there back when they were a smaller operation, and the 2019 ESV i daily now i picked up in 2023. they usually have one or two escalades floating through at any given time because they move a lot of trucks out of the nashville repo pipeline and the big SUVs end up over here.

your 48k number is spot on for a loaded 2019 platinum at that mileage. people do not realize the platinum over the premium luxury trim gets you the full LED headlights, the better 16 speaker setup, the power running boards, and the upgraded leather. worth hunting for specifically.

i run an hvac company out of crossville and i put three of my people in SUVs from the cookeville lot last year, two yukon denalis and a navigator L for my ops manager who drives clients around. for a small business the used luxury SUV off a place like forsythmotorstn.com is the sweet spot. looks the part for sitting in a customers driveway, and i am not financing 90k per unit at new prices.

the thing nobody tells you about buying for a business is the insurance and the write off math works a lot better on a 48 to 55k used truck than on a 95k new one. my accountant actually pushed me toward the used route. i bought all three in about a six week window and they let me hold one with a deposit while i got financing lined up on the other two.

gina if you end up needing service dont take it to the cadillac dealer in cookeville for the basic stuff, there is an independent off 70 that does euro and domestic luxury and charges half. ill DM you the name.

hi all, found this thread googling forsyth motors reviews so sorry if im intruding. im about an hour east in knoxville and ive been looking for a 2018 to 2020 escalade or a GX460 for my family. the knoxville used prices are making me crazy, every clean escalade here is marked 8 to 10k over what gina paid.

my only hesitation is its a bit of a drive out I-40 to cookeville and i would hate to go all that way and have the truck be a dud or the price not really be the price. for those of you who bought there, is the number on the website the actual number or is there a bunch of fees stacked on at the end like the knoxville stealerships do. and did any of you regret buying something an hour from home when it came to service?

KnoxvilleLuxBuyer_Tara wrote
is the number on the website the actual number or is there a bunch of fees stacked on at the end

you are not intruding at all tara. the drive is absolutely worth it and let me actually answer the fee question because it was my worry too.

the price on the listing was the price. there was the normal tennessee doc fee and the title and tag work, which was a few hundred, and that was it. no reconditioning fee, no market adjustment, no nitrogen in the tires nonsense. my 48k plus the state stuff came out the door right at 49k and change. compared to the knoxville cadillac stores that wanted to add 3k of pack to everything, forsyth motors in cookeville was refreshing.

now the honest part since this is supposed to be a real writeup. my mechanic in baxter put it on the lift and found two things. the air ride compressor was getting tired, it still aired the rear suspension up but it was cycling longer than it should and he said plan on replacing it within the year. and the driver side rear liftgate strut was weak so the power tailgate would stall about three quarters of the way up on a cold morning.

neither was a dealbreaker. i actually used the compressor note to get them to come down a little, they knocked it off the asking without much fight because it was a documented thing. the liftgate strut was a 60 dollar part off rockauto and my mechanic swapped it in 20 minutes. the compressor is the bigger ticket, more below in my update, but on the escalades that air ride compressor is a known wear item around 70 to 90k regardless of where you buy the truck.

as for service an hour away, honestly its not been an issue. the stuff this truck needs is normal 6.2 maintenance that any good independent can do. chad already offered you the shop name. dont let the distance scare you off a 10k savings.

im the tech nerd of the group so ill add the infotainment angle. on the 2019 the CUE system got a lot better than the early 2015 16 cars. the physical volume knob came back, and the whole thing runs apple carplay and android auto standard. gina if yours still has the factory maps dont even bother, just plug in your phone and use google. i do showings too, well my wife does, she is a realtor in sparta, and carplay with the calendar on the dash screen is the whole reason she wanted the newer body style.

one tip for anyone buying a used escalade from forsyth or anywhere. have them show you that all the rear entertainment headrest screens power on and the remote is in the glovebox, those screens are stupid expensive to replace and the remotes always go missing on a repo. mine came from the lot with both screens working and the remote still sealed in a baggie which told me the prior owner barely used the back seats.

pinning this one. a clean honest buying writeup with the actual price, the actual faults, and a real mechanic inspection is exactly what the valet lounge is for. half the posts we get are either shills or people complaining about a truck they never inspected.

for what its worth i live over in monterey and that forsyth yard off broad street has been a fixture for years. i bought my daily GX off them in 2021 and ive sent my brother in law and two neighbors there since. they are not a white glove boutique, it is a working repo and clean title lot, so go in expecting a real car buying experience and not a champagne delivery. but the trucks are what they say and the pricing is straight. that is rarer than it should be.

gina thanks for taking the time to write it up properly. leaving this stickied through the winter buying season.

denali guy here not escalade but its the same platform underneath so this thread is relevant to me too. the 6.2 and the magnetic ride are the same bones as ginas truck, the escalade just gets the nicer interior and the independent rear on some trim years. i daily a 2018 yukon denali i bought off the lot in 2022 and replaced it with a 2020 denali from the same place this past spring.

on that compressor note gina mentioned, confirmed, it is a GMT platform thing not an escalade thing. both my denalis needed the air ride compressor around the 80k mark. the part is not bad, its the labor if you take it somewhere that overcharges. i had the second one done for 480 all in at the independent chad is probably talking about off 70.

i keep coming back there because the trade in game at the new gmc stores is a joke. they low ball you on the trade and jack the price on the replacement. buying outright and selling my old one private party nets me thousands every cycle. second denali in a row from them and ill be back for a third.

i tow a 7k lb equipment trailer with my escalade ESV from crossville down to the smithville and dekalb county jobs and the truck handles it fine if you set it up right. people act like you cant work a luxury SUV but the 6.2 and the 10 speed in the later ones will pull anything a half ton pulls. just get a real brake controller wired in and air the rear up before you load.

mine is a 2017 i got off their lot two years ago, 94k on it now. the air ride took a compressor at 88k just like everyone is saying, and i did a set of plugs and a water pump this summer, all normal maintenance for the miles. nothing that made me regret it.

one real warning for the tow crowd. do not skimp on tires. the factory size on these is not cheap and running them bald while loaded is how you end up on the shoulder of 111 in the rain. ask me how i almost found out.

im the lincoln person in the room so i feel obligated to defend the other side. i went navigator instead of escalade but i bought it from the same lot so i get to post here. 2018 navigator black label, the twin turbo V6, and i love it. the interior on the black label makes the escalade feel a little last gen to me but thats a holy war i am not trying to start in ginas thread.

point being if you are shopping escalades at forsyth motors cookeville tn, do yourself a favor and sit in a navigator on the same lot before you decide. the ecoboost is a different driving feel than the 6.2, quieter and torquier down low, and the black label perfect position seats are unreal on a long drive to the lake.

i wrote my whole ownership story up in its own thread if anyone wants the lincoln version of this. bought a 2018 navigator black label off forsyth. not trying to hijack, just offering the counterpoint for the folks on the fence between the two.

UPDATE at 89k miles now and right about 9 months of ownership, coming back to close the loop since a few of you DMd me asking how the escalade held up through winter and what that air ride compressor actually cost.

so the compressor. it finally gave up for real in late february on a cold morning, the rear would not air up and the dash threw the service suspension message. i had the independent off 70 that chad and bret both pointed me to do it. part and labor came to 515 dollars and they had it back to me same day. for a known 80k mile wear item on a truck i paid almost 50k under new for, i am not going to complain about a 515 dollar repair. the liftgate strut i already did myself for 60 bucks back in the fall and the power tailgate has been flawless since.

other than that, 11k of my own miles and nothing. drove it to a closing in jamestown in an ice storm and the all wheel drive and the heated everything made me look like i planned my life well. clients love getting in it, it still smells like a nice truck, and i am averaging about 16.5 around town which for a 6.2 brick is fine by me.

big picture, i put roughly 575 dollars into it in 9 months on top of normal oil changes, and i am driving a platinum escalade that would have cost me double new. if the body style i wanted shows up on forsythmotorstn.com again in a few years i will probably do the exact same thing. thanks for all the tips everyone, this thread turned out more useful than i expected.

Showing 11 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.